Banner headline: NE Herts Labour Party
Last update to website:
11 July 2018

New on members' page

Ann Black's NEC report for July.

Some of the papers for the AGM on 25 July.

Papers for Letchworth & Baldock branch meeting.

Go to the members' page by clicking here.

Follow us on

You will need Adobe Reader for many documents on this website. Download it free.

Get Acrobat Reader

 On this page 

NHS Campaign Day

Analysis of the BBC report on the state of the NHS today after 70 years.

The  NHS's 70th birthday

Join our campaign to save the NHS in Letchworth on Saturday.

Our comments on Labour policy

As submitted to the National Policy Forum.

Tory rail mayhem

Campaigning in Royston, Baldock and Letchworth.

The Great Get Together

In Letchworth on 30 June, to keep Jo Cox's work going.

Additional money for grammar schools

Cei Whitehouse, writing in the Mercury, awards the government 2 out of 10 marks.

National Policy Forum consultation 2018

Meet to discuss Labour's policies on 12 June.

Alex Jarosy elected constituency party chair

Austerity hits North Herts

Big increase in requests for help from Citizens Advice.

Shocking cuts to local schools' budgets

Headteachers write to parents and carers again this year.

New contract results in uncollected food waste

Labour takes control in Letchworth

Gary Grindal and Helen Oliver on local involvement in the Area Committee.

Ian Albert on the challenges for all councils

Ian Albert's article from the Hertfordshire Mercury's Talking Point series.

Gary Grindal elected chair of Letchworth Area Committee

An additional seat for Labour in Letchworth

Kate Aspinwall wins Letchworth South East by eight votes.

Labour wins additional County seat

Roma Mills elected for St Albans North

Labour candidates at Royston market

Ready and willing to paint Royston red

Voter registration

Labour's manifesto for NH district elections

Tory councillor claims credit for keeping playground open

Tories confused on brown bin tax

Proportional representation

John Noolan of the Labour Campaign for Electoral Reform led a discussion at a constituency paty meeting.

Labour's alternative budget for Hertfordshire

Call to mitigate the worst impacts of the government's cuts to the county's funding.

Nascot Lawn

Parents win right to consultation before closure.

Leading by example

Labour's alternative budget for North Herts District.

Proportional representation

John Doolan of the Labour Campaign for Electoral Reform will lead a debate on 28 February.

Saturday 10 February - a great day for Labour

North Herts District campaign launch

Privatisation of the NHS

Jeremy Hunt's plans for American-style "Accountable Care Organisations" to be challenged in court by Stephen Hawking.

Death of Henry Sargent MBE

County's council tax up by 5.99%

Tories jump the gun in making this proposal.

"20 die after late arrival of ambulances"

according to Labour's Clive Lewis.

East Herts Rural New Year dinner

All members and families are invited.

Increased charges for social care

fall particularly on the most vulnerable.

There are earlier news items here
Click here for archived news item

How good is the NHS?

NHS campaign daySome of us can remember when you had to pay to see the doctor or have an operation. It was the luck of who our parents were whether our care could be afforded. Some of us even today have experienced, whilst on holiday in the USA, the awful feeling when you are asked for your credit card before you are asked what your symptoms are.

Aneurin Bevan, after he, as Health Minister in Clement Attlee's government, had brought in the NHS, famously said that it was "the envy of the world". Sure enough, much of the world copied it, with a few changes here and there. So, just how good is it now?

The BBC has commissioned a report from four very reputable bodies: the King's Fund, the Nuffield Trust, the Institute of Fiscal Studies and the Health Foundation. It compares health care in a range of developed countries. It demonstrates just how difficult it is to answer this question.

On equality of access, the NHS can hardly be faulted. They quote the American Commonwealth Fund survey which showed that the UK was much better than the average when people were asked if they had skipped  a consultation due to cost and was the best when they were asked if they had skipped a medicine prescription because of cost.

However, health care outcomes are something of a mixed bag. The NHS has a good record on diabetes, for example, and is the best at avoiding death from kidney disease. However, it is less good on some major health problems, such as heart attacks: for example, cancer survival rates are below average, although the rates over the ten years to 2014 have improved faster than the average.

But this needs to be put in context. The UK spends less of its wealth on health care (9.7%) than average (10.2%) - and much less than the USA spends on its largely dysfunctional system (17.2%). More importantly, it is less than France and Germany (11% and 11.3% respectively). This makes it difficult for anyone to argue that we cannot afford to pay for the NHS.

Of course, the GDP per person varies from country to country and the report also looks at spending per person. The UK is again below average by about 5% (10% if the USA is included). The figures are for 2016 and exclude capital spending, which might be an important factor, since the UK, for example, has 2.6 hospital beds per 1,000, compared with an average 4.5, and the lowest number of MRI and CT scanners.

We also lag behind on the number of doctors and nurses. We have one doctor for 356 people against an average of 277. The report speculates about how the numbers of our professional staff can be so far below average when our spending is closer to the average (albeit below it). They fail, however, to consider whether the cost of our present tendering system and the re-organization which has accompanied it, introduced by the Conservative-Liberal Democrat coalition government, is a factor. In effect, a whole new bureaucracy was added to our healthcare by that government.

We desperately need a Labour government to restore and develop the NHS, removing the bureaucracy of tendering for contracts and halting the creeping privatisation of services. That is why we were out today in Letchworth to mark the 70th birthday of the NHS and to campaign to prevent its disappearance into private hands before we can take it back for the good of the people.

7 July 2018

The NHS is 70 today

Happy birthday, NHS!Labour created the NHS 70 years ago today. It is our greatest achievement. Its creation was, of course, opposed by the Conservatives and, it has to be said, by the doctors. However, the doctors have been won over now.

The problem is that the Tories have not. They entered government in 2010 having promised not to re-organize the NHS, but immediately put forward a bill that radically altered the NHS, breaking it up in parts that could be put out to contract. Sadly, the Liberal Democrats, in coalition with the Conservatives, went along with this. 

The intention was clear. They expected that these contracts would be won by private companies, especially US health care providers. It did not quite go to plan. Many contracts did go to private companies, but the major American providers held back. Furthermore, against the odds, many contracts were won by NHS organizations, although at the expense of re-organizing themselves on commercial lines and spending scarce funds on the tendering process.

On top of this, the Conservatives have cut the growth of NHS funding and, in real terms, cut the pay of NHS staff. We all saw or read about the state of the NHS over last winter.

That’s why we shall be in Letchworth Town Centre next Saturday, 7 July, to celebrate Labour’s achievement and demand an end to the cuts, austerity and privatisation that have characterised the last eight years of Tory mismanagement of our NHS. We shall be handing out leaflets and talking to shoppers about how the Labour party will save our NHS.

Come and join us in Leys Square, near Esquires Coffee shop, Letchworth Town Centre, 10am to 2.30pm, on Saturday, 7 July 2018.

5 July  2018

Did you help to shape
Labour's manifesto?

National Policy Forum logoAn excellent meeting was held on 12 June 2018 to discuss the papers put forward by our Policy Commissions. Members split into small groups, each one discussing a different policy area: health inequalities, national education service, a greener Britain, the future of work, protecting our communities, and giving people power to shape their local communities. Their comments have now all been submitted to the National Policy Forum.

These comments are now available on the members' page of the website. In addition, there are comments on Labour's green paper on social housing, Housing for the Many. These comments were formulated by the East Herts Rural branch.

2 July 2018

Tory rail mayhem

Campaigning at Royston railway station

Labour, including our two Royston town councillors, at Royston station

The Labour Party was out campaigning about the state of our railways in Letchworth, Baldock and Royston. In Royston, on cue, the rail company delayed one train and advised passengers not to board the fast train because it was only four coaches and was already packed out on arrival.

Fittingly, this is also the first working day for the newly renationalised East Coast mainline. It is now twice that the private franchisee has been unable to run it and twice the state - that's you and me - has had to pick up the pieces. Last time, the nationalised railway company delivered high passenger satisfaction, as well as paying millions of pounds to the Treasury - but the Tories privatised it again, only to be forced to take it back into public ownership.

The Tories tell us that private companies are more efficient than nationalised organizations, but it is clear that they cannot get their figures right when they bid for franchises and they cannot get their timetables right either. Worse, apparently they assured the Secretary of State that all would be well with the new timetable, but now they say that in the north they will not be able to sort out the chaos until November!

25 June 2018

In honour of Jo Cox

We have more in common than that which divides usIt is two years since Jo Cox was murdered - murdered for her beliefs. But her beliefs live on.

Sue Ngwala, our political education officer, has arranged a second Great Get Together on Saturday 30 June 2018 to celebrate her life and ensure that those beliefs continue to be put into practice.

It is easy to show your support. You only have to eat a slice of cake. But you then need to go on living by her ideals - and that's not difficult either, if you put your mind to it.

23 June 2018

Government schools policy awarded 2 out of 10

Cei Whitehouse, who was our campaigns co-ordinator at the last general election, explains how the government is ignoring the evidence when it backs grammar schools. Writing in the Hertfordshire Mercury on 7 June 2018, he explains why he gives them only 2 out of 10 - "Must try harder". The article is below.

This was set alongside an article by Cllr Jeff Jones (Buntingford, Conservative) which perfectly illustrates the Tories' flawed grasp of the evidence.

Cei's article is below:

Articl;e on grammar schools by Cei Whitehouse

9 June 2018

Help shape Labour's next manifesto

National Policy Forum consultation 2018The 2017 Labour Manifesto is widely thought to have contributed to the remarkable upsurge in Labour support that took place between the council elections in May and the General Election in June 2017.

We are now working on the manifesto for the next general election and your input really can make a difference. We are meeting to discuss policies next Tuesday, 12 June 2018 at 7.30 pm in the Mrs Howard Memorial Hall, Norton Way South, Letchworth SG6 1NX. (The Hall is across the road from the Howard Gardens Social Centre where the constituency party usually meets and there is a car park alongside the hall.)

Please read the consultation documents on the subjects that interest you, so that you can make your contribution. Each document sets out some background information and a set of questions that need to be answered. Those familiar with earlier policy consultation documents will find that these are commendably short.

The subjects are:

You can access all these documents on the Labour Policy Forum website.

We look forward to seeing you. If you are not known to the officers of the constituency party, please remember to bring your membership card with you.

6 June 2018

Welcome to the chair, Alex

Alex JarosyAlex Jarosy was elected chair of the constituency Labour Party (CLP) at the all-member meeting on 20 May 2018, filling the vacancy left when Doug Swanney resigned earlier in the year. At an earlier meeting, the CLP had decided not to leave the vacancy open until the AGM in July. However, all constituency party posts, including chair, will be up for election at the AGM.

Alex has been membership secretary of the CLP and will continue to hold this post until the AGM. Alex comes with a long history of campaigning in London and recently in elections in our constituency. He has worked in local government at a senior level and with housing associations.

31 May 2018

Tory austerity is hitting
North Herts

Cllr Gary Grindal"Tory policy is clearly having a damaging impact on the most vulnerable in North Herts," said Gary Grindal (pictured right), our Labour and Co-operative councillor for Letchworth Wilbury, after he had seen the report for 2017/8 from Citizens Advice North Hertfordshire.

Compared with the previous year, client issues were up by 20%, principally because people are being hit in several ways by the government's austerity programme: the number of issues per client was up by 15%.

Nearly a third of the problems related to benefits and taxes, and the number was up by 21%, followed by debt (up by 9%) and housing (up by 16%). In addition to debt problems, the need for help with budgeting more than doubled.

The highest number of benefit cases related to the Personal Independence Payment (PIP). One effect of the change-over from Disability Living Allowance has been on the charges which disabled people have to pay for care workers to assist them. Labour county councillors have tried to prevent the Tory County Council from taking advantage of the change to increase charges for the most disabled (see below).

PIP, together with Employment Support Allowance and Housing Benefit, make up more than half the benefits cases, but Universal Credit cases have more than doubled as this form of benefit is rolled out.

We are fortunate that Citizens Advice has kept going in spite of the withdrawal of local authority funding over recent years and it is good to know that even more people are volunteering their help: volunteer numbers were up 38% since the year before.

"In North Herts, this volunteering organisation helped 5,400 people in the last year," said Gary Grindal. "They remain so vitally important in our community."

30 May 2018

Tory government hits
our schools again

Shock at further cuts for local schools

Letter to parents from head teachers For the second year in a row, local Head Teachers have felt compelled to write to parents, explaining the devastating effect on our schools of funding cuts.

The letter that we have seen outlines some of the effects of previous cuts on one particular school:

The letter goes on to warn that further reductions in teaching staff may be necessary, resulting in larger cleases at key stage 4, withrawal of some options at GCSE and a reduced range of A-level courses. In addition, before and after school provision may be at risk. The letter, which is signed by all the secondary heads in North Hertfordshire, calls on parents to write to their MP and to government ministers.

Cllr Judi BillingJudi Billing, Leader of the Labour Group on the County Council and Spokesperson for Education, Libraries & Localism (pictured), says: "It’s really shocking that in a comparatively wealthy place like North Herts all six of our Secondary Heads feel they must explain to parents and students that they expect standards and choices to decline simply for lack of cash. 

"The teachers and leaders at our schools are amongst the the most committed professionals you could ever meet. It's nothing short of a scandal that the government is making it harder and harder for them to deliver the education that they care so much about and that our children need.

"The Secretary of State Damian Hinds should be ashamed of himself and I hope that every North Herts parent will make it clear to him that this funding gap is completely unacceptable for our schools, our teachers and our children in 2018."

Last May, at the Generel Election hustings in Royston, Member of Parliament for NE Herts, Sir Oliver Heald, assured parents that Theresa May had a plan to tackle school funding issues. Despite those assurances, a year on, our children's schools have made cuts, and will be making further cuts, which affect our children's education.

You can read about last year's letter from headteachers here.

26 May 2018

Food waste goes uncollected

The change of contract for food waste collectioin in North Herts to Urbaser has led to food waste caddies being left out on the kerb for nearly a week.

Cllr Elizabeth Dennis Harburg5Cllr Elizabeth Dennis Harburg, Labour's shadow portfolio holder for refuse and waste management, said: "One of the most vital statutory services provided by NHDC, the contract for food waste collection, has been chronically affected by the switch over to Urbaser with new routes and "data errors" being blamed.

Labour councillors on North Herts District have spent the last few days hearing from residents in both Hitchin and Letchworth and raising problems with the Council. In some instances, whole streets have had their unemptied food waste caddies out on the kerb for nearly a week.

To make matters worse, there are many reports of unanswered phones, making reporting the missed collections unnecessarily difficult. And sporadic responses to online fault reporting.

Labour has, therefore, requested a full statement from both NHDC and Urbaser, outlining a clear plan for how they will rectify the problems as rapidly as possible - and how they'll literally clean up the mess."

24 May 2018

Labour take control of
Letchworth Area Committee

Change is coming: get involved

Cllrs Grindal and OliverThe results of the 2018 District Council Elections have brought change in Letchworth, as the Local Area Committee passes into Labour control. The new Chair, Cllr Gary Grindal, pledges to enable local people to use the meeting to get involved and make their voices heard.

Gary explains, “When we were knocking on people’s doors during the election, it wasn’t so much to talk, as to listen; people definitely needed that, because unfortunately they’ve felt ignored - it’s time for that to change. A fresh ethos will shape how Letchworth’s Labour councillors manage the Local Area Committee, ensuring that we encourage engagement across the town.

"We’ll be asking local community groups, charities and even individuals to come along and make presentations, ask questions or share petitions. We’re looking forward to building stronger links with small local businesses and those working for the local community.

"Whilst both NHDC and the County Council remain in Conservative control, it doesn’t stop Letchworth Councillors and the Local Area Committee from engaging with and supporting our community, seeking improvements where we can, sharing what we’ve learned and challenging decisions, if consultation hasn’t been taken into proper account.”

Grange Cllr Helen Oliver will be supporting Cllr Grindal in the role as Vice Chair. Helen added, “We’ve an enthusiastic, energetic and motivated team of Labour councillors ready to support our town. We’re keen to see local people engage with their Area Committee, so look out for notices of our meetings, or get in touch with me at, to find out how to take part.”

More cuts to come

Ian Albert outlines the problems facing North Herts Council

Image of Mercury articleValue for money is the key issue as North Herts District Council faces cuts of 40% in its funding in the next two years. Writing in the Hertfordshire Mercury on 17 May 2018, Cllr Ian Albert (Labour and Co-operative, Hitchin Bearton), who is the finance lead for Labour on the council, gives a clear view of the challenges faced by all councils as a result of the government's austerity programme, which has fallen most heavily on local authorities.

You can read his article here.

19 May 2018

Gary Grindal to chair
Letchworth Area Committee

Cllr Gary GrindalCllr Helen OliverCllr Gary Grindal, just re-elected as our councillor for Letchworth Wilbury, has been elected as the chair of the Letchworth Area Committee, with Cllr Helen Oliver, newly elected as our councillor for Letchworth Grange, as vice-chair.

Over in neighbouring Hitchin, Cllr Ian Albert (Labour and Co-operative, Hitchin Bearton) will be chairing the Hitchin Area Committee.

18 May 2018

We've won an additional seat in Letchworth

Yesterday we successfully defended four seats that we already held in Letchworth and also won an extra seat in Letchworth South East.

Gary GrindalSue NgwalaDaniel AllenHelen OliverKate Aspinwall

Gary Grindal, with new councillors, Sue Ngwala, Daniel Allen, Helen Oliver and Kate Aspinwall

In Letchworth Wilbury Gary Grindal retained his seat on the Council, with a majority of 454 over the Tory candidate and with over 58% of the vote.

Sue Ngwala won Letchworth East, taking over from the popular and well-known Lorna Kercher, who has recently moved away. Sue had a comfortable majority of 394 over the Tory, with nearly 52% of the vote.

In Letchworth Grange, Helen Oliver and Daniel Allen had majorities of 114 and 119 respectively over their nearest Tory rival. They replace Labour's Clare Billing and Sandra Lunn. Sandra did not stand again, but Clare Billing stood for a seat in her home town of Hitchin, where she won comfortably.

In Letchworth South East, Kate Aspinwall won the seat from the Conservatives with a majority of just eight. The other candidates, including a UKIP candidate, lagged well behind.

Rob InwoodAmy Bourke-WaiteIn Baldock Town, Alec Maguire lost to the Tory candidate, but was well ahead of the Liberal Democrat and the Green candidates. Similarly in Royston Palace, Rob Inwood was second to the Conservative and ahead of the other two parties. Rob Inwood (pictured right) was, however, re-elected to Royston Town Council and Amy Bourke-Waite (pictured left), formerly our vice-chair (membership), was also elected to the Town Council.  

In the other two Royston seats, Ken Garland and Jess Finn fared less well. In both cases, the Liberal Democrats had something of a resurgence. In Royston Heath, they actually took the seat from the sitting Conservative councillor.

Our neighbours in Hitchin held two seats that they were defending and also gained a seat in Hitchin Walsworth, by a hefty majority.

For more information about the candidates and to see their election addresses, go to the Election page.

For detailed figures, and for the results in the rest of North Herts, go to the North Herts District Council website

4 May 2018

Labour wins one more County Council seat

Cllr Roma MillsRoma Mills has won back her seat on the County Council, taking the St Albans North division for Labour. A by-election for this seat took place at the same time as district council elections. This brings the strength of the Labour Group up to ten. 

She had a majority of 319 over the Liberal Democrat candidate. The Conservative candidate came third.

Roma was also re-elected to the St Albans City and District Council.

4 May 2018

Painting Royston red

Rob Inwood and his team at Royston market

Three District Council candidates at Royston market:  (from left) Alec Maguire, Rob Inwood and Jess Finn, with supporters

When the Tory District Councillors implement the Tory Government's swingeing cuts on local government, whilst giving themselves yet another increase in their allowances, it is time to strengthen the opposition, to try to preserve our services in North Herts.

Rob Inwood is the Labour and Co-operative candidate for Royston Palace and Jess Finn is the Labour candidate for Royston Meridian. Alec Maguire, who is our candidate in Baldock Town, was visiting to give his support. Rob Inwood is also standing for re-election to the Town Council and John Rees (on the right of the picture) is a town council candidate as well.

There is more information about the election and our candidates on the election page.

14 April 2018

Are you registered to vote?
Do you need a postal vote?

register to voteIf you are not registered to vote, you have until 17 April to register in time for the district council elections on 3 May. It's very easy to register - go to You will need your National Insurance number.

If you have moved recently, you need to register at your new address. Your registration is not transferred to your new address by the council, even if they are aware that you are paying council tax at the new address.

If you think that you may not be able to get to the polling station on election day, you should apply for a postal vote. You have until 5pm on 18 April to apply.There is more information on how to apply here.

7 April 2018 (revised 13 April)

Labour's manifesto for
North Hertfordshire

District Council elections on 3 May

Cover of NH manifesto 2018

We will keep the play parks open in North Herts and we will scrap the bin tax. We will provide genuinely affordable, quality homes and make sure that developers provide the facilities that are needed. This, and more, is set out in Labour's manifesto for the North Herts District Council elections on 3 May 2018, which can be read here.

There will be elections in all five of the Letchworth wards, all three Royston wards and in Baldock Town ward. We are defending four seats in Letchworth. The other seats up for election are held by Tory councillors. There is also an election for all the seats on the Royston Town Council.

For information on Labour candidates, please go to the Elections page.

We need people to deliver leaflets and targeted letters over the Easter weekend. Email the Campaign Co-ordinator at if you can help.

31 March 2018

Tory councillor infuriates
local campaigners

Playground campaigners

Letchworth playground campaigners last summer

Last weekend local residents in Hitchin Walsworth received a "newsletter" - of sorts -  from Conservative District Councillor Alan Millard. In it he seemed to imply some responsibility for a recommendation before the next Cabinet meeting to continue maintaining local Rosehill playground. The letter infuriated members of the campaigning group "Save Our Parks - Hitchin" and local Labour Councillors alike - as Mr Millard had not been an active part of the hard work put in to save this valued community space.

Labour Councillor Elizabeh Dennis said: "Looking back on the excellent campaign at Rosehill, I remember it was led by motivated local people, concerned about their playground. I was proud to be part of that campaign and support those families, to help them make their voices heard. I don’t remember Cllr Millard coming along to listen, nor offer encouragement.

"If our residents are to place trust in local democracy, councillors need to be clear and open about their position on local issues – or it disrespects the hard-work put in by those trying to make a difference and share the views of their community."

In any case, the Tory proposal is to retain the play equipment "for the time being" and appears to relate to just this one playground. Elizabeth Dennis continued: "Residents in and around Linnet Close playground in Letchworth, including local Labour Candidate for the Grange, Helen Oliver, organised to show how treasured their playground was – yet it remains planned for closure."

The Labour manifesto for the election in May makes it clear that they would claw back the increase in councillors' allowances which the Tories awarded in the last two years to help to keep local playgrounds.

14 March 2018

Tories confused about
their own bin tax

As North Herts Tories spent last weekend apparently confused about the details of their own plans for the “bin tax”, local Labour’s alternative could not be clearer.

Cllr Ian AlbertA confusing tweet from @NorthHertsTories on Friday, asserting that residents could pay the 40 “brown bin tax” in instalments, has resulted in North Herts District Council having to inform residents once again that this is not the case – the new charge must be paid in one lump sum.

Labour Councillor Ian Albert (pictured) said: “First, the Conservatives ignored resident consultation, which was overwhelmingly against this change, then they were unable to answer a number of our questions when the “brown bin tax” was scrutinised, then a letter was sent to residents about the charges - with no contact telephone number and no postal address. Now it seems they are even confused about how residents must pay the 40 charge.

"In contrast we’ve been clear that we oppose the charge. A Labour run Council for North Herts would work to bring an end to the charge. If the Tories insist on introducing it, there needs to be clear communications, the ability to pay in instalments and proper concessions for groups such as the elderly and disabled."

Ian Albert continued: "Local Labour are clearly offering an alternative to what feels like a panicked and confused response to national government’s relentless slashes to our Council’s funding; over the next two years this Council faces a further reduction in funding of more than 40%, a savage attack on essential local services. However, it’s a political choice to starve Local Government of funding and Labour Councillors would make different choices when dealing with it."

In the Oversight and Scrutiny Committee, the Tories all voted against referring the brown bin charge to the full Council. In East Herts the decision was referred to the full Council and, although the two councils have joined forces to award the contract for refuse collection, East Herts Council decided not to introduce the tax.

See previous news item for more information.

13 March 2018

Campaigning to change
the voting system

John Doolan of the LCEROur first-past-the-post voting system ensures that right-wing parties can govern with around 37% of the vote. John Doolan, a member of the executive committee of the Labour Campaign for Electoral Reform (LCER), spoke at an all-member meeting of the constituency Labour Party last night and set out why, in his view, the present system was broken.

At present, the system results in a very narrow debate on how best to influence swing voters, most of whom are not very interested in politics anyway, rather than on the major policies to benefit the country, he argued.

The aim of LCER was to get the Labour Party to accept that the first-past-the-post system should be replaced and then to enter the debate about which system of proportional representation (PR) to propose in the manifesto for adoption by the next Labour government.

In the ensuing, lively debate, he admitted that coalitions were more likely, but contested the view that these would be arrived at through deals behind closed doors. He said that, for example in the Netherlands, parties spelt out in advance what sort of deals they might enter into. He believed also that policies resulting from agreement between coalition partners were more difficult to reverse.

He countered the suggestion that the referendum which decisively rejected the alternative vote system (AV) made PR an unviable policy for Labour at the moment by explaining that AV was not truly PR. As a result, the right wing press and the Tories had found it very easy to rubbish.

Of course, PR would allow more parties to gain MPs and, in the recent past, UKIP would have gained some seats in Parliament. He suggested that this would have shown them up for what they really were.

An indicative vote in the well-attended meeting showed a majority in favour of PR, but with several opponents and several who had not made up their minds.

1 March 2018

The blame lies with the Tory government

Labour's alternative budget for Hertfordshire

Cllr Sharon TaylorSharon Taylor, Labour County Councillor for Stevenage Bedwell, introducing Labour's amendment to the Tory budget for the county for 2018/9, put the blame for the cuts squarely on the Tory government. "We recognise the impossible position the council has been placed in by its own government," she said.

"The appalling treatment of local goverrnment in successive austerity-driven budgets will go down in history as the most unprecedented and concerted attack on localism and local services this country has ever seen. 16bn of cuts between 2010 and 2020."

She drew attention to the predicted 5.8bn gap in adult care services funding and the rising demand for child protection, leading to a gap of 2bn or more by 2020.

So, Labour could only "seek to mitigate the worst impacts on our most vulnerable residents" and to show the importance of making this a "county of opportunity for all of our younger residents".

So, Labour proposed a fully costed amendment to redeploy some of the money available - principally money being set aside for future use - to allow the Council to:

The proposals were rejected by the Tory-dominated council, but show how Labour could make things better, even in the impossible situation created by the government. There is more on the increase in the county's council tax precept here.

27 Februayr 2018

Stay of execution for
Nascot Lawn

For the second time, the High Court has quashed the decision of the Herts Valleys Clinical Commissioning Group (CCG) to close the Nascot Lawn respite centre, which provides respite care for severely disabled children throughout Hertfordshire. (See earlier reports below.)

Chhris Ostrowski, Labour candidate for WatfordParents, who have been supported throughout their struggle to keep Nascot Lawn open by Labour councillors Nigel Bell and Asif Khan, mounted the challenge. The CCG is required to cut 45m from its spending in the current financial year and have tried to argue throughout that they did not have to support the centre because it was a care facility, not a medical facility. The judge has now ruled that it is a medical facility, that they must consult with the County Council and that they must hold a public consultation before they can make a decision to close the facility. The service must continue to be provided at least until August.

Chris Ostrowski (pictured), Labour's parliamentary candidate for Watford, where the centre is located, said: "I am so pleased for the parents. Their determination and campaigning has been rewarded. I call upon the CCG and the Government to abandon this closure. The root cause is the 45 million of Tory government cuts to west Hertfordshire's NHS. I would expect the local MP and Mayor to be campaigning for more funding for our local NHS."

23 February 2018

Tories reject call to
"lead by example"

Cllr Ian AlbertLabour councillors on North Herts District Council called on the Tories to lead by example. Recognising that the Council faces the imposition of a further 40% cut to its budget by the Tory government, they proposed that they should end the bin tax and stop the closure of play parks by reducing councillors' allowances.

However, the Tories rejected Labour's fully costed alternative budget and went ahead with their own budget with the brown bin tax and the closure of children's play parks, and an increase in councillors' allowances of 2%, on top of the 10% increase last year.

Cllr Ian Albert (Labour, Hitchin Bearton, pictured above) explained: "This Council faces ...a savage attack on essential local services provided by our hard-pressed staff. However, we reject Cllr Cunningham's view that considering cuts to our front-line services or outsourcing public amenities are a sad inevitability. Labour would make different choices.

"We won't close playgrounds. Young people are our future. We'll lead by example. We need to correct the damage of the 10% increase (in councillors' allowances) last year. We propose a reduction. Furthermore, we propose to end the costly civic reception. There are far better ways to honour our local community and raise money for charity than a three-course meal on the taxpayer."

20 Feburary 2018

Should Labour back proportional representation?

John DoolanThe Labour Campaign for Electoral Reform campaigns to change Labour policy to support for a voting system on a more proportional system. They believe it is in everyone’s interest, including the Labour Party’s, to do this. John Doolan will be speaking on this and leading a debate on this topic at the constituency party's all-member meeting on 28th February 2018.

This meeting is open to all members and affiliated supporters. There is also some business to transact. An agenda has been sent to members, but a revised version will be sent to them shortly.

As usual the meeting is at 7.30 pm at Howard Gardens Social Centre, Norton Way South, Letchworth SG6 1SU.

19 February 2018

Saturday was a great day
for Labour

Campaign launch for North Herts electionsOn Saturday, the North Herts District Election campaign was launched with a flourish in Hitchin Town Square. No one in the square that morning can have missed the red campaign stall and the large number of supporters who came to suppport the candidates for election throughout the district.

North Herts District Council has elections every year for one -third of the seats, except in the year of County Council elections. Within in our constituency there are elections on 3 May 2018 in all the seats in Letchworth and in Royston, as well as in the Baldock Town ward. Three of these seats are currently held by Labour: Letchworth Wilbury, Letchworth Grange and Letchworth East.

There are, of course, also wards with elections in the neighbouring Hitchin and Harpenden constituency and this was the joint launch in both constituencies.   The picture shows campaigners from our constituency in Hitchin Town Square.

East Herts Rural branch dinner

That evening, several of those who had been campaigning in Hitchin joined members of the East Herts Rural branch for their annual fund-raising dinner, which was held in the Axe and Compasses in Braughing.

East Herts Rural branch dinnerCllr Judi Billing, who is a North Herts District Councillor, but is also a Hertfordshire County Councillor and Labour Group Leader on that council, came to talk about the important work that is done by the County Council and the effect that the currently small group of Labour councillors can have. Judi is at the head of the table in the picture and Rachel Burgin, our interim campaign co-ordinator for the elections this May is on the right.

The dinner raised 242 for branch funds - essential for the branch to fight East Herts District Council elections next year and for such contingencies as an unexpected General Election!

12 February 2018

Campaign launch

North Herts District Council elections on 3 May

We shall be launching our campaign tomorrow, 10 February 2018, along with our colleagues from the Hitchin and Harpenden constituency. The launch will be at 10.30 am at a stall in Hitchin Town Square SG5 1DY, where local electors can find out about Labour's alternative District Council budget, the Labour manifesto for these election and how to make sure that they are registered to vote.

Cllr Ian AlbertCandidates, councillors and local campaigners will be at the stall from 10.30 am until 12 noon. Come and join us. Look our for the red gazebo!

"We'll be happy to answer people's questions on our fully costed budget," says Cllr Ian Albert (pictured), "which puts residents first and reflects Labour's understanding that the District Council provides important services, not just numbers at the bottom of a page of cuts. We know it's possible to give these services the funding they deserve."

Last Saturday, local campaigners were out in Letchworth, talking to shoppers, hearing their views on issues from charging for brown bins to Conservative councillors awarding themselves another allowance increase. Come along to Hitchin on Saturday to give us your views. "It will be great to get the chance to share our plans and listen to the public, because our manifesto is focused on our commitment to genuine consultation," says Ian Albert.

9 February 2018

Hunt aims to speed up privatisation of NHS

But Stephen Hawkins wins right to challenge the changes

Jeremy Hunt, the Secretary of State for Health and Social Care, had planned to lay regulations allowing so-called Accountable Care Organisations (ACOs) to take over all the NHS services, as well as social services, in a particular area.

This was discussed briefly at the constituency party meeting addressed by Stephen Gill of the Socialist Health Association (SHA) in November (see below).

The NHS is disappearing before your eyes ....This form or organisation would mean that the whole NHS service in a particular area - from GP surgeries up to acute hospitals would be put out to tender to be taken over by a private company, who may itself run the whole of the service or sub-contract parts of it to others. It may also include social services, taken over from the democratic control of local councils.

The result looks very like privatisation of the NHS. The level of service would be set by the terms of the contract and would not be in the day-to-day control of NHS bodies. Eventually, it could mean that the whole of the NHS was privately provided.

There are already companies providing this "service" in the USA. One can imagine that this change, which has not gone before Parliament, aims to attract American companies, such as Kaiser Permanente. This is in spite of the fact that American healthcare is hardly a model that we should want to follow, since it costs twice as much as our healthcare and overall has considerably worse outcomes.

The good news now is that it was announced during last week that Prof. Stephen Hawking has won the right to have a full judicial review of the lawfulness of setting up ACOs. He and leading healthcare professionals argue that the change to such organisations requires an Act of Parliament, so that the Commons and the Lords can scrutinise the proposal.


The whole of the drive towards NHS privatisation seems to have begun in 2002 with an article in the British Medical Journal, which claimed that Kaiser Permanente achieved better results than the NHS at roughly the same cost. However, it was subsequently shown that the comparison was not valid and that the Kaiser model was actually very much more expensive than the NHS.

A variant of this system is about to come into force for Cornwall. The county council, run by a coalition of Liberal Democrats and Independents, proposes to take over the NHS services and care services from 1 April 2018 in an "Accountable Care System", which they distinguish from an ACO. Whilst the incorporation of care services into the same system as health is to be welcomed, this does open up the possibility of the council contracting out some or all of the services to private companies. 

However, Jeremy Hunt has drawn back from authorising this because no consultation has taken place. Even so, this major change in the type of orgnaisation put out to tender has not been subject to Parliamentary debate. It has not even been debated by Cornwall County Council! You can read more about this on the old website of the North Cornwall Labour Party, under both Press Releases and Cornwall Issues.

4 February 2018

Former Labour mayor dies

Henry Sargent MBE, former Mayor of HertfordIt is with great sadness that we report the death of Henry Sargent MBE, at the age of 93. He was twice Mayor of Hertford - and the first Labour Mayor. He served on Hertford Town Council for many years and was instrumental in setting up the Hertford Music Festival.

From this constituency's point of view, his importance was his service as a district councillor on East Herts District Council, although for a ward outside our present constituency. For many years, he was the sole Labour councillor, until he was joined by one other and then, in 1995, by seven others. He was leader of this enlarged Labour Group for one year until he stood down from that role.

He will be remembered for his kindness to all who worked with him, his support for younger members coming on behind him, and for his cheerfulness in spite of the Conservative domination of the district council.

His funeral is next Monday, 5 February 2018 at 1 pm at St Joseph's Church, St John's Street, Hertford SG14 1RX. All who knew him are welcome. There will be refreshments in the church hall afterwards. Family flowers only. We understand that there will be an opportunity, announced at the funeral, to make a donation in his memory.

31 January 2018

Tories propose increase in County's council tax of 5.99%

Cllr Judi BillingThe increase in the council tax would be made up of 3% for social care and 2.99% for other services, this being the largest increase allowed by the government without a referendum.

You may wonder why you have not heard what Labour's counter-proposals for next year's budget are. This is because the Tory proposal has not yet been debated. It is a proposal from the Tory Cabinet. The Tories have jumped the gun before going through the due processes of the county council. It has yet to go to the Scrutiny Committee, where the opposition parties can have their say, and for agreement by the full Council.

Labour will bring forward its proposals at the correct time, when they can be properly debated. Judi Billing, the Labour Group leader, says: "It rather makes a mockery of the democratic process and makes me wonder why they bother to pretend that they want to seriously listen to the views of all."

It is notable that the Tories are expecting that their government funding will be cut once again - this time by 22m.

28 January 2018

Ambulance crisis in
East of England

"20 died after late arrival of ambulances," says MP

Clive Lewis MPClive Lewis, the Labour MP for Norwich South (right), has said that 20 people died in the East of England - an area which includes Hertfordshire - in the period between 18 December 2017 and 3 January 2018, after ambulances arrived late.

A senior member of the ambulance staff told HSJ (Health Service Journal) that at least 40 patients were "harmed or died following significant ambulance delays" in the East of England in this period.

An ambulance service spokesman said that in this period "on just one day in that period our ambulance crews spent more than 117 hours waiting to hand over patients to the care of hospitals".

"Our findings will likely show that a number of these incidents were caused by delays in reaching patients," he added.

The NHS is disappearing before your eyesThe government Health Minister told the Commons that a "risk summit" had been set up. However, it is becoming increasingly obvious that our hospitals are over-stretched, partly because patients cannot be released through lack of social care, which results in over-crowding in A&E departments, with the result that ambulance crews have to hang around outside hospitals or in hospital corridors with their patients, and therefore are not available to respond to new 999 calls.

The Tories will tell you that they have increased funding to the NHS this year, but not that funding has dropped well below the funding in Germany or France.

24 January 2018

East Herts rural New Year dinner invitationAll members and affiliated supporters, their families and friends are invited to the East Herts Rural branch's dinner. They will receive a warm welcome.

The speaker is Judi Billing, the leader of the Labour Group on the County Council, who will tell us of the importance of this Labour voice, at present only nine councillors, on the Tory-dominated council.

Please book by 2 February and give us your menu choices. You can access the menu here.

22 January 2018

The most disabled pay more
under the Tories

Disabled generic pictureIt is the most disabled who will suffer most under the changes to charges for social care services, set to be introduced by the Tory County Council from 15 April this year.

"The proposal would negatively impact upon ..... the sustainability of their care and ability to stay at home. which could result in higher costs across the health and social care system," says the charity, Carers in Hertfordshire.

Some new charges affect all users of the particular service, like the doubling of the charge of transport to and from day care centres, from 2 to 4, and a weekly charge of 3.25 per week for telecare services provided by Serco.

Other changes fall especially on the most disabled. Previously, if two care workers were needed to assist the disabled person, the second worker was not charged for, but a charge will now be made. Also, when means-testing  was carried out to determine payments, the higher rate disability living allowance (DLA) was ignored and the middle rate assumed, on the grounds that the higher rate was only awarded if care at night was required. The new personal independence payment (PIP) does not include this criterion and the Council will therefore take the higher payment fully into account in the means test.

The proposal for these increases goes to the full Council on 20 February 2018. Carers in Hertfordshire have started a petition. This is at present 126 short of the 1,000 needed for presentation to the Council. Please sign the petition here.

21 January 2018

Site map

Labour's red rose
Hosted by Ltd., Units H, J, K, Gateway 1000, Whittle Way, Stevenage, Herts. SG1 2FP. Promoted by David Bell, on behalf of North East Hertfordshire Labour Party, both of Town Farm House, Mill End, Standon, Ware, Herts SG11 1LP.